She Goes by Jane

Episode 139
Missing
The Empty Seat: The Disappearance of Thora Chamberlain
Campbell, California
Content Note:
This episode contains discussions of violence against children.
Her Story
On November 2, 1945, fourteen-year-old Thora Chamberlain left school in Campbell, California, expecting to attend a football game that evening.
Her friends saved her a seat.
Thora never arrived.
Witnesses later reported seeing her speaking with a man dressed as a serviceman before getting into his vehicle. Within weeks, investigators focused on Thomas McMonigle, a local laborer with a history of violence. Over the course of the investigation, McMonigle gave multiple confessions, led authorities to key pieces of evidence, and was ultimately convicted of Thora's murder.
But investigators never found the one thing that mattered most.
Thora herself.
More than eighty years later, Thora Chamberlain remains one of California's earliest no-body homicide victims. Her body has never been recovered.
In this episode, we examine the disappearance of Thora Chamberlain, the investigation that followed, and the evidence that secured a conviction despite the absence of a body.
This is a story about loss, memory, and the empty seat left behind when a child never comes home.
AT A GLANCE
AT A GLANCE
Name
Thora Chamberlain
Age when last seen
14
Last seen
Campbell, California
Date
November 2, 1945
Status
Missing
NamUs Case Number
#MP36923
If you know something
Contact the Campbell Police Department at (408) 866-2101

ABOUT THE READER
Aimee Baker
Aimee Baker is the author of the poetry collection Doe (University of Akron Press 2018) about missing and unidentified women. She is also the co-host of this podcast.
Sources
“2 school girls fail to identify McMonigle.” The San Francisco News, February 6, 1946.
“2nd slaying ‘confessed’.” The San Francisco Examiner, January 6, 1946.
“3 Peninsula girls identify kidnap suspect.” The San Francisco Examiner, December 14, 1945.
“51 arrests still to be made under indictments.” The Telegraph, November 19, 1934.
“72 witness McMonigle death in gas chamber.” The San Francisco Examiner, February 21, 1948.
“Accused slayer visited by wife.” The Times, December 25, 1945.
“Beachcomber free in death probe.” The Times Herald, May 11, 1946.
“Belmont clew discovered in lost girl case.” The San Francisco Examiner, November 8, 1945.
“Belmont girls give clue in hunt for SJ girl.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, November 7, 1945.
“Chamberlain girl believed slain in hills.” The Times, December 12, 1945.
“Chamberlain suspect grilled.” The Times, December 13, 1945.
“Coastside hunt for S.F. wife.” The San Francisco News, April 26, 1946.
“Court upholds child slayers’ convictions.” The Bakersfield Californian, February 18, 1947.
De Roos, Robert. “The McMonigle Trial.” San Francisco Chronicle, February 7, 1946.
“Death of Mrs. Hogmire unexplained.” San Francisco Chronicle, May 4, 1946.
“Death to be demanded for Thora killer.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, December 17, 1945.
“Delay McMonigle trial till Monday.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, January 31, 1946.
“Devil’s Slide death riddle.” The San Francisco Examiner, May 4, 1946.
“Devil’s Slide mystery man, lie detector end in a draw.” San Francisco Chronicle, May 9, 1946.
“Devil’s Slide victim’s mate held for quiz.” The San Francisco Examiner, May 3, 1946.
“Doomed convict offers body for science to restore life.” The Sacramento Bee,March 13, 1947.
“Doomed killer in final try to save life.” The San Francisco News, February 18, 1948.
“Doomed murderer offers body for ‘life after death’ experiment.” Los Angeles Evening Citizen News, March 13, 1947.
“Ex-bus driver confesses kidnap, murder of Thora Chamberlain.” The San Francisco Examiner, December 16, 1945.
“Ex-wife sees McMonigle.” The San Francisco Examiner, March 12, 1947.
“FBI enters Chamberlain kidnap case.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, November 14, 1945.
“Fear missing girl, 15, kidnapped.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, November 5, 1945.
“Find corpse hurled over coast cliff.” The Press Democrat, April 20, 1946.
“Garment found in sand given to authorities.” The Times, December 29, 1945.
“Girl clothing found.” The Times, December 14, 1945.
“Girl slaying jury meets in garage.” The Times-Herald, February 15, 1946.
“Held for vagrancy.” The Edwardsville Intelligencer, October 23, 1933.
“Hogmore thinks wife may be kidnap victim.” The Times, April 26, 1946.
“Insantity plea is McMonigle’s only hope now.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, February 20, 1946.
“Judge rejects McMonigle plea.” The Times, December 2, 1947.
“Kidnap-killer held.” The San Francisco News, December 15, 1945.
“Kidnap-slayer’s trial set Jan 1.” The San Francisco News, December 18, 1945.
“Kidnap slaying locale changed.” The San Francisco Examiner, January 4, 1946.
“Lie detector test supports Hogmire.” Redwood City Tribune, May 8, 1946.
“Link McMonigle to S.F. Girl Case.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, February 1, 1946.
“M’Mongle’s boast of being with girl told.” The San Francisco News, February 7, 1946.
“M’Monigle case jurisdiction hit.” The San Francisco News, February 14, 1946.
“M’Monigle charges FBI threats.” The San Francisco News, February 8, 1946.
“M’Monigle gives sixth death story.” The San Francisco News, February 18, 1946.
“M’Monigle guilty.” The San Francisco News, February 19, 1946.
“M’Monigle jury to hear of girl ’s frantic SOS.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, February 2, 1946.
“M’Monigle’s latest story.” The San Francisco Examiner, February 13, 1946.
“M’Monigle on trial today.” The San Francisco Examiner, January 30, 1946.
“M’Monigle takes stand; weaves new story.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, February 18, 1946.
“M’Monigle wins 90-day delay.” The Times, June 17, 1947.
“McMonigle boast about girl is told in court.” The Californian, February 7, 1946.
“McMonigle’s confession of killing girl is ready to jury.” The Sacramento Bee, February 13, 1946.
“McMonigle executed for murder.” The Bakersfield Californian, February 20, 1948.
“McMonigle fails to lead searchers to body of his murder victim.” The Modesto Bee, April 25, 1946.
“McMonigle gets death penalty.” The San Francisco Fall Bulletin, March 1, 1946.
“McMonigle gives court new story.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, February 18. 1946.
“McMonigle granted reprieve.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, September 12, 1947.
“McMonigle in 5th confession of ‘murder.’ The Independent, February 12, 1946.
“McMonigle in Quentin admits body found is one of his victims.” Santa Cruz Sentinel, April 21, 1946.
McMonigle is sane; must die for crime.” The Sacramento Bee, February 26, 1946.
“McMonigle jury to inspect Thora death car.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, February 13, 1946.
“McMonigle map leads to search for body of Thora Chamberlain.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, February 18, 1948.
“McMonigle may be right.” The San Francisco News, February 1, 1946.
“McMonigle planned to get girl near here.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, February 13, 1946.
“McMonigle says girl died on road west of Campbell.” Santa Cruz Sentinel, February 19, 1946.
“McMonigle trial started.” The Californian, January 30, 1946.
“McMonigle repudiates first three confessions.” The San Francisco Examiner, February 1, 1946.
“McMonigle’s Undoing.” San Francisco Chronicle, December 16, 1945.
“McMonigle ‘Waited’ in cafe, 5 to testify.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, February 6, 1946.
“McMonigle wins 30-day stay.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, December 5, 1947.
“McMonigle wins court hearing.” The Modesto Bee, June 10, 1947.
“Missing mate found dead, husband held.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, May 2, 1946.
“Missing wife’s body found.” The San Francisco News, May 2, 1946.
“More witnesses identify McMonigle as man with Thora.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, February 6, 1946.
“Mother, father tell of girl’s disappearance.” The Californian, February 5, 1946.
“Mrs. M’Monigle gets death bid.” The San Francisco Examiner, January 12, 1948.
“Mrs. McMonigle to leave mate.” The San Francisco News, January 24, 1946.
“Mrs. McMonigle won’t stand by.” Oakland Tribune, January 25, 1946.
“New evidence in M’Monigle case.” The San Francisco News, April 20, 1946.
“New McMonigle clues sought.” The Times, January 1, 1946.
“New McMonigle confession is called time bid.” The Sacramento Bee, February 12, 1946.
“No accidents on highways here Monday.” Santa Cruz Sentinel, September 5, 1944.
“Parents appeal to abductor of daughter.” The Sacramento Bee, November 8, 1945.
“Parents of missing girl continue vigil for telephone call.” The Springfield News-Leader, November 8, 1945.
“Peninsula Cafe watched in hunt for missing girl, 15.” The San Francisco News, November 6, 1945.
“Pleas entered by M’Monigle.” The San Francisco Examiner, January 5, 1946.
“Resurrection plea denied to McMonigle.” The Times, March 14, 1947.
“San Jose girl’s murder confessed by ex-felon.” Oakland Tribune, December 16, 1945.
“San Jose woman may have seen girl kidnapped.” The Sacramento Bee, February 2, 1946.
“Says M’Monigle dated girl of 15.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, February 7, 1946.
“Schoolmates helping to hunt valley girl.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, November 5, 1945.
“Search fails third day for Mrs. Hogmire.” The Times, April 27, 1946.
“Search for missing San Jose bobby-soxer in Long Beach.” Daily News, November 7, 1945.
“Search opens for schoolgirl lured by man offering job.” Democrat and Chronicle, November 6, 1945.
“Second girl killing pinned to M’Monigle.” The San Francisco Examiner, February 22, 1946.
“S.F. Crime laid to McMonigle.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, February 21, 1946.
“S.F. girl may be victim of McMonigle.” San Francisco Chronicle, February 2, 1946.
“Slayer pleads innocence as life ends.” The Times Standard, February 20, 1948.
“Slayer’s wife wins divorce in RC court.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, March 5, 1946.
“Statewide search on for missing girl.” Oakland Tribune, November 5, 1945.
“Statewide search ordered for lost high school girl.” The Daily Breeze, November 5, 1945.
“Telegraph clue to San Jose missing girl branded fake.” The Times-Herald, November 7, 1945.
“Testimony by Rountree ires Tom M’Monigle.” Santa Cruz Sentinel, October 1, 1947.
“Thora’s books found in dump at Burlingame.” The Peninsula Times Tribune, January 21, 1946.
“Thora Chamberlain’s sister polio victim.” The Times, August 17, 1949.
“Thora’s parents to face accused killer in court.” The San Francisco Call Bulletin, February 4, 1946.
“Thora’s watch, ring found in killer’s home.” The San Francisco Examiner, February 28, 1946.
“Two vagrants arrested here.” The Vincennes Sun-Commercial, December 4, 1932.
“Victim buried in yard, says McMonigle.” The Sacramento Union, February 14, 1946.
“Wife sues kidnap, murder suspect.” Los Angeles Evening Citizen News, February 1, 1946.
“Youth held for alleged attack on aged woman.” The Telegraph, June 5, 1934.