She Goes by Jane

Episode 162
Unidentfied
The Woman Behind the Gordon Mountain Ghost
Schuylkill County, Pennsylvania
Content Note:
This episode contains conversations about sexual violence, sex trafficking, and murder.
Her Story
On April 5, 1925, a couple picking wildflowers on Broad Mountain in Schuylkill County, Pennsylvania, found the body of a young woman. She’d been murdered. More than a century later, Broad Mountain Jane Doe has never been identified, and her killer has never been found. Most people know her only as the Ghost of Gordon Mountain.
Before she was a ghost story, though, she was a young woman in an olive green sweater with six rings on her fingers wearing a string of cheap pearls. In this episode, Aimee and Vanessa follow the discovery of her body and the search for her name. They cover the girls and women she was mistaken for, the Sunset Inn and other roadhouses of Schuylkill County the newspapers called a “port of missing girls,” and the local men who, by their own account, staged the appearance of a “ghost” up on the mountain for thrill-seekers hoping to catch a glimpse of the Gordon Mountain Ghost.
AT A GLANCE
AT A GLANCE
Name
Broad Mountain Jane Doe or Gordon Mountain Jane Doe
Age when last seen
estimated 20-30
Last seen
Schuylkill County, Pennsylvania
Date
discovered April 5, 1925
Status
Unidentified
NamUs Case Number
there is no NamUs entry
If you know something
There is no active case for this murder victim.

ABOUT THE READER
Mary Lewis
Mary Lewis is an actress, screenwriter, and film and television director. She is the recipient of multiple awards for her directing and screenwriting work including a Genie, a Gemini, Best Film Awards at AIFF, TIFF, VIFF, Yorkton, Dawson City, Columbus, San Jose’s Cinequest, Laguna Beach Film Festivals, Flicks International Film Festival as well as the ARTS-NL Artist of the Year Award. She has a long list of credits on stage and screen as well as audiobooks. She was born in Kampala and raised in St. John’s, Newfoundland.
Sources
“29 girls vanish; search.” Mount Carmel Item, April 28, 1925.
“50 dollars usual price paid to girl traffickers.” Mount Carmel The Daily News, May 14, 1925.
“‘Broad Mountain Ghost’--fact or fiction.” Pottsville Republican, October 31, 1981.
“Broad Mountain had more than one ‘famous ghost’.” The News Item, Jan 17, 1973.
“Broad Mountain Murder Mystery may be reopened.” The Daily News, June 6, 1925.
“Broad Mountain Road shunned by motorists who fear apparitions.” Shamokin News-Dispatch, July 15, 1925.
“Check up on girls; mystery.” Mount Carmel Item, April 10, 1925.
“Corpse found on Broad Mountain is identified as body of Lillian “Babe” Tyler of Shamokin.” Mount Carmel Item, April 14, 1925.
Devlin, Ron. “Ghost of Gordon Mountain legend persists.” Republican Herald, March 29, 2025.
“Dr. Spencer denies he made statement in murder case.” Mount Carmel Item, April 30, 1925.
“Find new clue into mountain slaying.” The Evening News, June 10, 1925.
“Five held in connection with Broad Mountain case are released under bail.” Mount Carmel Item, April 15, 1925.
“Girl positive that mountain victim was 16-year-old Marie Sheldon.” Lancaster Daily Intelligencer, June 12, 1925.
“Girl who left grips here is believed to be the one killed.” Mount Carmel Item, April 9, 1925.
“Lillian Tyler reports to police in Detroit, Mich.” Mount Carmel Item, May 1, 1925.
“Local girl identified head of murdered girl.” Mount Carmel Item, April 20, 1925.
“Local men witnesses in murder mystery.” Mount Carmel Item, April 11, 1925.
“Local people, held as witnesses in murder case, are denied bail.” Mount Carmel Item, April 13, 1925.
“Mother identified murder victim through ghost she sees on Broad Mountain.” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, August 18, 1925.
“Mother fails to identify head as that of daughter.” Mount Carmel Item, April 15, 1925.
“Mrs. O’Connor says her daughter will be in Shamokin soon.” Mount Carmel Item, April 18, 1925.
“Murder mystery deepens.” Mount Carmel Item, April 27, 1935.
“Murdered woman was dead or unconscious when she was burned.” Mount Carmel Item, April 7, 1925.
“Network of evidence to show Louis Muff trafficked in girls in white slavery.” The Daily News, April 14, 1925. I don't have
“Partly charred body of girl found on mountain; identified this afternoon.” Mount Carmel Item, April 6, 1925.
“Police still think burned body is that of Miss Tyler.” Mount Carmel Item, April 16, 1925.
“Road houses close since girl murder.” Mount Carmel Item, April 17, 1925.
“Seek ghost on Broad Mountain.” Standard-Speaker, July 23, 1925.
Serfrass, Donald. “Spotlight: Unsolved murder haunts Schuylkill County.” Times News, October 27, 2018.
“Startling disclosures in girl traffic in this part of state are anticipated.” Mount Carmel Daily News, May 13, 1925.
“State-wide attention being given “ghost” on Broad Mountain.” Mount Carmel Item, July 23, 1935.
“Sunset Inn is closed.” Mount Carmel Item, May 12, 1925.
“Sunset Inn is robbed.” Mount Carmel Item, April 17, 1925.
“The real story about the Broad Mountain Ghost.” Republican and Herald, January 18, 1973.
“Two murders, similar in detail, now baffle police Indiana and Pennsylvania.” Mount Carmel Item, April 29, 1925.
“Woman supposed murdered is found.” Mount Carmel Item, April 8, 1925.