She Goes by Jane

Episode 146
Missing
The Missing Women of Pinellas County: Margaret Dash, Retha Hiers, Donyelle Johnson | Part 1
Pinellas County, Florida
Content Note:
This episode contains discussions of intimate partner violence.
Her Story
Three women disappeared from Pinellas County, Florida over the course of fifteen years.
They came from different backgrounds. Their lives followed different paths. But their disappearances would eventually point investigators toward the same man.
In 1974, Margaret Dash left home to buy medicine for a sick relative and never returned. In 1982, Retha Hiers drove out to buy laundry detergent and vanished. In 1989, college student Donyelle Johnson left for class but never arrived.
Each woman left behind a family searching for answers. Decades later, investigators would come to suspect Cleveland Hill Jr., a married former minister and asphalt contractor with a documented history of violence who was repeatedly investigated but never charged in connection with their disappearances.
This week, we examine the lives of Margaret Dash, Retha Hiers, and Donyelle Johnson, the evidence that links their cases, and the unanswered questions that continue to haunt Pinellas County more than fifty years after Margaret first disappeared.
AT A GLANCE
AT A GLANCE
Name
Margaret Dash, Retha Hiers, and Donyelle Johnson
Age when last seen
Margaret Dash, 38; Retha Hiers, 43; Donyelle Johnson, 21
Last seen
Pinellas County, Florida
Date
Margaret Dash, June 14, 1974; Retha Hiers, December 28, 1982; Donyelle Johnson, April 4, 1989
Status
Missing
NamUs Case Number
#MP2931 (Margaret); #MP10462 (Retha); #MP10470 (Donyelle)
If you know something
Contact the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office at (727) 582-6200

ABOUT THE READER
Malynda Hale
Malynda Hale is an award-winning actress, filmmaker, singer-songwriter, and storyteller based in Los Angeles. Most recently, she starred in the feature film Bull Street alongside Loretta Devine and Amy Madigan and made her directorial debut with the short film Curtain Call, which screened at festivals internationally including Bend Film Festival, GAZE International LGBTQIA Festival, and Middlebury NewFilmmakers Festival. Her second short film, Au Gratin, starring Tiffany Daniels, Loretta Devine, and Jay Donnell, was selected for the Poppy Jasper International Film Festival and Wyoming International Film Festival, and will also screen at the LightReel Film Festival in Washington, D.C. and the Martha’s Vineyard African American Film Festival in August, an Oscar-qualifying festival. She is also the founder of JMV Entertainment, a production company focused on developing film, television, and media projects rooted in meaningful storytelling.
Sources
22-061 Detectives Conduct Excavation on a Property in Largo.” Pinellas Sheriff’s Office, July 7, 2022.
Barstow, David. “Nearly 2 dozen arrested in cola-cocaine sting.” Tampa Bay Times, September 20, 1990.
Births. Tampa Bay Times, June 14, 1966.
Burney, Teresa. “Neighborhood businessman offers to help out Omni Center.” Tampa Bay Times, March 12, 1986.
“Charges reduced for man in Pinellas shooting spree.” The Tampa Tribune, April 26, 1968.
“Crooks’ coke deal fizzles, landing them in the can.” The Daytona Beach News-Journal, September 22, 1990.
Divorce Judgements. Tampa Bay Times, June 35, 1968.
Divorces. Tampa Bay Times, February 3, 1968.
Fay, Michael. “Dealers get Coke for coke.” The Tampa Tribune, September 20, 1990.
“Hill is given probation.” Tampa Bay Times, July 19, 1968/
Hill v. State. District Court of Appeals, Second District. Docket No. 83-1019. December 2, 1983.
“Largo woman searched for in Orlando.” The Orlando Sentinel, May 11, 1989.
Lee, Demorris A. “Again, tragedy strikes family.” Tampa Bay Times, April 23, 2008.
Leiser, Janet. “Cops hope to dig up clues to mysteries.” The Tampa Tribune, April 14, 1993.
Leiser, Janet. “Digging for bodies called off.” The Tampa Tribune, April 15, 1993.
Lesier, Janet and William Yelverton. “Vanished.” The Tampa Tribune, September 9, 1993.
“Man calls Pinellas, surrenders.” Tampa Bay Times, February 7, 1968.
“Man wanted in shooting arrested.” The Tampa Tribune, February 10, 1968.
Matter of Hill (Bankr.M.D.Fla 1983), United States Bankruptcy Court, Bankruptcy No 83-1329. August 22, 1983.
Meinhardt, Jane. “Officials dig for clues in old case.” Tampa Bay Times, April 14, 1993.
“Missing woman.” The Orlando Sentinel, May 11, 1989.
Molloy, Mary Claire and Caroline Petrow-Cohen. “A Legacy of Pain.” Tampa Bay Times, August 21, 2022.
Morgan, Richard. “Serviceman husband hunted. Two women are shot.” Tampa Bay Times, Feb 6, 1968.
“Pinellas County issues warrants in double shooting.” The Tampa Tribune, Feb 7, 1968.
“Police arrest three after trading Coke for coke.” Tallahassee Democrat, September 21, 1990.
Roberton, Craig. “Husband shot in argument over money.” Tampa Bay Times, May 21, 1977.
Weber, Natalie. “Pinellas deputies search for body from 1980s cold case.” Tampa Bay Times, June 30, 2022.
“Women shot in Pinellas.” The Tampa Tribune, Feb 6, 1968.