top of page
Cynthia Maine She Goes by Jane

Episode 143

Missing

San Diego's Lost Women: Cynthia Maine | Episode 1

San Diego, California

Content Note:

This episode contains discussions of sex work, police violence, drug use, and murder.

Her Story

In the 1980s, dozens of women disappeared from San Diego, California. One of them was 26-year-old Cynthia Maine.

Cynthia was a daughter, sister, mother, and woman trying to survive addiction while working along El Cajon Boulevard, San Diego’s notorious red light district. By 1986, she was rebuilding her life. She had found work as a waitress, but she was also serving as a police informant. Just months before she vanished, she had allegedly begun an affair with one of her police contacts.

Late in February, she told her family she was going to watch a movie.

She never came home.

As investigators searched for Cynthia, few realized they were witnessing the beginning of one of the largest unsolved series of murders and disappearances in California history.

In the first episode of this three-part investigation, we examine Cynthia's disappearance alongside the murder of her friend Donna Gentile. Together, their stories reveal a hidden world of vice squads, confidential informants, police corruption, and the extraordinary risks faced by women living on the margins of San Diego in the mid-1980s.

This series asks how so many women could disappear from one city and why so many of their cases remain unsolved decades later.

AT A GLANCE

AT A GLANCE

Name

Cynthia Maine

Age when last seen

26

Last seen

San Diego, California

Date

February 21, 1986

Status

Missing

NamUs Case Number

#MP8606

If you know something

Contact the San Diego Police Department at (619) 531-2000

Aimee Baker

ABOUT THE READER

Aimee Baker

Aimee Baker is the author of the poetry collection Doe (University of Akron Press 2018) about missing and unidentified women. She is also the co-host of this podcast.

Sources

“5th prostitute found strangled.” Daily Times-Advocate, February 13, 1986.

“Body found: Sept. 26, 1985.” Daily Times-Advocate, August 30, 1987.

“Convict goes on trial for slayings.” North Country Times, February 15, 1994.


“California inmate accused of killing 2 in serial case.” The Bellingham Herald, September 17, 1991.

“Detectives fear serial killer is stalking prostitutes in rural San Diego.” Daily Press, October 8, 1987.


“Face of unidentified murder victim recreated by task force.” The Californian, September 13, 1990.

“Former detective files $12M lawsuit.” North County Times, October 2, 1991.

“Fresno man sought in San Diego killing.” The Fresno Bee, February 21, 1986.

Galvan, Louis, "Fresno man sought in San Diego killing.” The Fresno Bee, February 21, 1986.


Gladfelter, Jacqueline. “Escondido man guilty of murder.” The Californian, September 23, 1992.

Groves, Seli. “Linda Gray: Looking for justice in high-powered film.” The Spokesman Review, April 27, 1993.

Hecht, Peter. “Green River Killer in San Diego?” The Sacramento Bee, August 15, 1988.

“Innocent plea in strangulation death.” Imperial Beach Star-News, March 2, 1986.


“Killer is sentenced.” The Fresno Bee, July 16, 1992.


“Killer gets 13 years.” Daily Times-Advocate, April 29, 1987.


Limberg, Jerry Kathleen. “The Murder of Donna Gentile: San Diego Policing and Prostitution 1980-1993.” Department of History thesis, California State University San Marcos, 2012.


Platte, Mark. “3 Officers Suspended in Team Inquiry.” The Los Angeles Times, November 7, 1991.

“Man to stand trial for stabbings.” Daily Times-Advocate, January 31, 1986.

“Mechanic gets four years in prison for sexual attack.” Daily Times-Advocate, April 5, 1989.

“Missing prostitute had links to police.” Daily Times-Advocate, September 26, 1990.


Moore, Judith. “Where is Cynthia McVey?” San Diego Reader, January 10, 1991.

“No serial killer, police say.” Daily Times-Advocate, February 18, 1986.

“Officials identify woman’s body.” North Country Times, August 3, 1988.


Platte, Mark. “2 officers in probe won’t be charged.” Los Angeles Times, July 24, 1991.


Platte, Mark. “6 years after death, family still waiting: tragedy” parents didn’t learn that their daughter was a possible slaying victim until the controversial NHI art project was in the works.” Los Angeles Times, April 5, 1992.


Platte, Mark. “The Homicide Task Force Was a Tangled Web.” Los Angeles Times, August 21, 1991.


Platte, Mark. “Informant’s Claim of Liaison with Sergeant is probed.” Los Angeles Times, December 6, 1990.


Platte, Mark. “Probe of Police Reveals Only Petty Offenses.” Los Angeles Times, July 31, 1991.


Platte, Mark. “Rape report wasn’t passed on to task force.” Los Angeles Times, July 9, 1991.


Platte, Mark. “Task Force prove is second look at officer’s link to prostitution.” Los Angeles Times, September 27, 1990.


“Police targeted in slayings.” Camarillo Star, September 28, 1990.

Renner, Maxene. “Monroe officials search for crime link.” The La Crosse Tribune, June 11, 1993.

“Reward is offered for woman’s killer.” Chula Vista Star-News, February 2, 1986.

Rivenburg, Roy. “Suspect granted delay.” Daily Times-Advocate, December 23, 1988.


“San Diego officers suspended.” The Desert Sun, November 8, 1991.

“San Diego County Digest.” The Los Angeles Times, March 27, 1990.

“Serial killer feared on the loose near San Diego.” The Union, October 8, 1987.


Serrano, Richard A. “2 listed as serial killer victims.” Los Angeles Times, September 8, 1988.


Serrano, Richard A. “A Trail of Death: Is Serial Killer Behind Slaying of 29 Women, Mostly Streetwalkers in the County?” Los Angeles Times, October 5, 1987.


Serrano, Richard A. “Task Force is renewed in prostitutes’ killings.” Los Angeles Times, March 14, 1989.

“Slain woman may be 5th victim of killer.” Camarillo Star, February 13, 1986.

Spearnak, Catherine. “A pattern of death.” Daily Times-Advocate, August 30, 1987.

Spearnak, Catherine. “Investigation into killings widens.” Daily Times-Advocate, September 29, 1987.


Spearnak, Catherine. “Lady Killer.” San Diego Magazine, May 1988.

“Strangled woman identified.” North Country Times, June 25, 1987.

“Suspect in choking nabbed.” North Country Times, October 13, 1988.

“Wanted man.” Imperial Beach Star-News, September 22, 1985.

“Woman found slain on I-805 identified.” Chula Vista Star-News, January 9, 1986.

bottom of page